In its best moments, ‘The War of the Rohirrim’ is truly a sight to behold. With a fascinating blend of anime's arresting surrealism and the introspective wonder of Miyazaki, this Lord of the Rings movie displays its magical capabilities. The brief instances of artistic brilliance leave a lasting impression, hinting at a breathtaking visual adventure.
Regrettably, these moments are short-lived and scattered throughout the movie. The narrative fails to build on those exceptional scenes and, instead, falls back into a more cautious storytelling style. One that, despite the epic battles and visually stunning imagery, eventually blends into the background as a forgettable myth-making exercise.
This reluctance to take risks and fully explore the possibilities offered by the anime style is disheartening. A bolder approach would have effectively set this film apart from the more traditional Western-style animated features, leveraging the creative freedom of anime to produce something truly memorable.
Regardless of its inability to break new ground, ‘The War of the Rohirrim’ still showcases some impressive animation. Character designs and action sequences capture the essence of the Lord of the Rings universe, further enriching the world's lore and providing a glimpse into Middle-earth's captivating history.
Overall, while the movie may not live up to expectations as a game-changing anime adaptation, it remains an engaging addition to the Lord of the Rings collection. Its unique visual style and historical insight will undoubtedly enthrall fans, but it also leaves us wondering what could have been if the filmmakers took a bolder approach to storytelling.