Rangers' $20 Million Dollar Question: Panarin or Shesterkin, Who's the Real MVP?

The 2023-2024 NHL season is underway, and the New York Rangers are off to a strong start. With their high-powered offense and elite goaltending, many are expecting them to make a deep playoff run. However, with great expectations come great debates, and one of the most intriguing discussions surrounding the Rangers is the value of two of their star players: Artemi Panarin and Igor Shesterkin.

Artemi Panarin, the high-scoring left wing, has been one of the most dominant players in the league since signing a seven-year, $81.5 million contract with the Rangers in 2019. He has consistently produced at an elite level, scoring at least 90 points in each of his first three seasons with the team. Panarin's incredible speed, agility, and puck-handling skills make him almost impossible to defend, and his ability to create scoring chances for himself and his teammates has been a game-changer for the Rangers.

Igor Shesterkin, on the other hand, has been a revelation in goal for the Rangers. The 25-year-old Russian goaltender has been nothing short of phenomenal since taking over as the team's starter, posting a 2.45 goals-against average and a .920 save percentage in his first two seasons. Shesterkin's incredible athleticism, quick reflexes, and ability to read the game have made him one of the top goaltenders in the league, and his presence in the crease has given the Rangers a sense of security and stability that they haven't had in years.

So, who's more valuable to the Rangers: Panarin or Shesterkin? It's a tough question, as both players have been instrumental in the team's success. However, if we look at the numbers and the impact each player has on the game, it's clear that both Panarin and Shesterkin bring unique qualities to the table that make them difficult to replace.

One argument for Panarin being more valuable is that his production is irreplaceable. The Rangers' offense relies heavily on Panarin's ability to create scoring chances, and without him, the team would likely struggle to score goals. Additionally, Panarin's speed and agility make him a matchup nightmare for opposing teams, and his presence on the ice opens up space for other players to create.

On the other hand, Shesterkin's goaltending has been just as crucial to the Rangers' success. His ability to make big saves and shut the door in critical situations has given the team a sense of confidence and momentum. Without Shesterkin, the Rangers would likely struggle to keep up with the high-powered offenses of the Eastern Conference.

Ultimately, the answer to the question depends on how you value different aspects of the game. If you prioritize scoring and production, Panarin is likely the more valuable player. However, if you prioritize goaltending and defense, Shesterkin is likely the more valuable player. Either way, it's clear that both Panarin and Shesterkin are essential to the Rangers' success, and the team will need their best efforts to make a deep playoff run.